Skip To Content
Follow Us
6 Shops Across New York
Call +1 212 555 0187
Whole Pies, 18 Inches

Eight Slices, One Box, No Arguments

Every slice on our board is also a whole pie, out of the deck oven twenty-five minutes after you order. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet.

An arugula and parmesan pie from above Pies From$24
The Special

Sweet, Hot And Salty In One Fold

Hot Honey Soppressata: spicy cups, mozzarella and chili honey. Twelve pies a day, then the board says sold out.

A hot honey soppressata pie from above Special$34
Pickup Or Delivery

Order By Five, Dinner By Half Past

Pick a shop and a time; the pie goes in the oven to land on it. Delivery in four boroughs.

A sicilian pie from above 25 MinHot
0103
4.8Google rating from 2,417 reviews

What New York Says

“Forget the trendy spots. This is the slice New York folds for.”

Maya Robinson · Williamsburg regular
Choose Your Pie

The Best Pie Menu In Town

Plain Cheese Classic

Plain Cheese

60Vegetarian
$24.00 18" Pie
Pepperoni Best Seller

Pepperoni

97
$28.00 18" Pie
Margherita

Margherita

282Vegetarian
$28.00 18" Pie
White Pie

White Pie

208Vegetarian
$31.00 18" Pie
Vodka Sauce Hot

Vodka Sauce

245Vegetarian
$31.00 18" Pie
Hot Honey Soppressata Special

Hot Honey Soppressata

79Spicy
$34.00 18" Pie
Buffalo Chicken

Buffalo Chicken

116Spicy
$33.00 18" Pie
Veggie Supreme

Veggie Supreme

153Vegetarian
$31.00 18" Pie
Mushroom & Truffle Special

Mushroom & Truffle

190Vegetarian
$36.00 18" Pie
Pesto & Ricotta

Pesto & Ricotta

227Vegetarian
$31.00 18" Pie
Today

Pie Of The Day: Arugula & Parm

Tomato pie finished with arugula, shaved parmesan, lemon.

The pie of the day, up close
A whole pie with one slice pulled away
The Stretch

One Slice, All The Cheese

Low-moisture mozzarella melted at 650°F pulls into strings and holds the fold. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit.

  • DoughThree Days Cold
  • Deck Oven650°F Stone
  • A Whole Pie18", Eight Slices
  • CheeseLow-Moisture Mozzarella
Deals By The Hour

Specials With A Clock

The deal that is on right now lights up. Online codes work in the bag only inside their hours.

Mon, Tue, Wed, Thu, Fri

Weekday Lunch

15% off any order, Monday to Friday, 11 am to 3 pm.

  • At The CounterTwo slices and a soda for $9.50 at the counter.
  • Online CodeLUNCH15
Wed

Pie Day Wednesday

$5 off every whole pie, all day Wednesday.

  • At The CounterEvery whole pie $5 off, pickup or delivery.
  • Online CodePIEDAY
Fri, Sat

Late Night

$4 off orders over $25 after 11 pm on Friday and Saturday.

  • At The CounterAny slice $3 after 11 pm in East Village.
  • Online CodeLATE4
Sun

Sunday Family Pies

10% off orders with two or more whole pies on Sunday.

  • At The CounterTwo pies and a dozen knots for the table.
  • Online CodeFAMILY10
A Slice For The Road

Go Ahead, Get The Third Slice. We Won’t Judge.

Said At The Counter

Folded, Tipped, Reviewed

4.8Google rating from 2,417 reviews

“The Pepperoni Cups Hold A Little Pool Of Oil.”

That is the whole review. Fold it, tip it, eat it standing at the counter. The board said Just Out and it was.

Maya RobinsonMaya RobinsonWilliamsburg regular

“Came For Open Mic, Stayed For Three Slices.”

I did four minutes on my landlord and nobody threw anything. The white pie is the real headliner.

Leo MarchettiLeo MarchettiTuesday open mic, twice a month

“My Kids Still Talk About The Sunday Class.”

They stretched the dough, argued about toppings and carried their own pies home in their own boxes.

Priya NatarajanPriya NatarajanAstoria, mom of two

“Best 2 AM Slice On St Marks.”

Hot, crisp, folded in paper and handed over by someone who was clearly having a better night than me.

Jordan EllisJordan EllisNight owl since 2019
Pickup Or Delivery

Order Your Pies

Everything you put in the bag is here. Pick up at any of the six shops in the next slot from its oven, or have it brought to your door.

Pickup Or Delivery?

Where And When

Pickup at East Village.

Your Details

Ways To Reach Us

The Original Counter

128 St Marks Place, New York, NY 10009

All Six Shops

Call The Counter

+1 212 555 0187
Pies, tickets and parties, every day

Call Now

Write To Us

example@example.com
We answer within a day

Send An Email

Open Late

East Village till 1:00 am
Friday & Saturday till 4:00 am

Open Daily
Say Hello

Get In Touch

Questions about a pie, a ticket, a party or a job: write to us and a real person answers.

Send Us A Message